Entries tagged [security]
Meltdown and Spectre patches show negligible impact to Apache Ignite performance
As promised in my initial blog post on this matter, Apache Ignite community applied security patches against the notorious Meltdown Spectre vulnerabilities and completed performance testing of general operations and workloads that are typical for Ignite deployments.
The security patches were applied only for CVE-2017-5754 (Meltdown) and CVE-2017-5753 (Spectre Variant 1) vulnerabilities. The patches for CVE-2017-5715 (Spectre Variant 2) for the hardware the community used for testing are not stable yet an can cause system reboot issues or another unpredictable behavior.
The applied patches have shown that the performance implications are negligible - the performance drop is just in the 0 - 7% range as the figure shows:
Thus, Apache Ignite community highly recommends its customers and partners to consider security patches for CVE-2017-5754 (Meltdown) and CVE-2017-5753 (Spectre Variant 1) in their deployment environments and contact us on the user list if you run into a larger performance drop in your use case.
At the same time, we're keeping an eye on Intel announcements and will validate the performance implications of Spectre Variant 2 once a solution is released by the hardware vendor.
Just for your reference, the benchmarks were executed in the following environment and configuration.
- 4 servers and 8 client nodes
- Apache Ignite version: 2.4.0
- Huawei RH2288 V3, CPU - 2x Xeon E5-2609 v4, 1.7GHz, RAM - 96Gb, SSD - 3x800Gb RAID0 2.4Tb, Network - 10Gb/s
- DEll R610, CPU - 2x Xeon X5570, RAM - 96Gb, SSD - 512Gb, HDD - 2048GB, Network - 10Gb/s
- OS CentOS Linux release 7.4.1708 (Core)
- Kernel - Linux 3.10.0-693.11.6.el7.x86_64 #1 SMP Thu Jan 4 01:06:37 UTC 2018 x86_64
Protecting Apache Ignite from 'Meltdown' and 'Spectre' vulnerabilities
The world was rocked after the recent disclosure of the Meltdown and Spectre vulnerabilities that literally affect almost all software ever developed. Both issues are related to the way all modern CPUs are designed and this is why they have opened unprecedented security breaches -- making the software, including Apache Ignite, vulnerable to hacker attacks.
The vulnerabilities are registered in the National Vulnerability Database under the following CVEs:
How to protect Apache Ignite deployments?
First, the vulnerabilities can be fixed only on the operating system (OS) or hardware levels. All OS and hardware vendors are working on and releasing patches to fill-in the security breaches. Depending on the type of your Apache Ignite deployment, make sure to do the following:
- On-premise deployments - apply the patches prepared by your OS and hardware vendors. Consult with them to find out additional steps to act on. This page is a good place to start with.
- Cloud deployments - major cloud providers such as Amazon and Microsoft are in a process of patching their cloud computing services. Consider a cloud provider's security announcements and recommendations or follow up with a representative for suggestions.
Second, an Apache Ignite cluster becomes vulnerable to the attacks only if someone gets unauthorized access to cluster machines (both on-premise or cloud deployments) and executes a malicious shell script or connects to the cluster directly and executes a Java, .NET or C++ computation there.
Do the following to prevent this from happening:
- Make sure the cluster machines are secured with a hard-to-guess or hard-to-calculate password.
- Consider using 3rd party security components provided by enterprise vendors (such as this one) to strengthen a security shield of your deployments.
Finally, researchers who discovered Meltdown and Spectre have said that the first issue can be fixed with software patches while the second can be fully addressed only with hardware upgrades/replacement. Luckily, it's much more difficult for hackers to exploit Spectre. Thus, if the two recommendations given above are taken seriously, the chances that you will be impacted from Spectre are low.
What is the performance impact of security patches?
Many security patches are rolled out with a precaution that some of the applications can see up to a 30% performance degradation. Apache Ignite community is planning to measure the impact of general usage scenarios and will follow up with the results in a consequent post.
This general performance testing might not cover your use case. Therefore, it's highly recommended that you assess and test a possible performance drop of your Apache Ignite deployments before applying the patches in production. If the drop is significant, then contact us on the dev list.